Benjamin is a gunsmith and runs the gun store in Thieves' Landing, which he took possession of sometime between 1907 and 1911.
Events of Red Dead Redemption[]
The player can buy ammo and weapons from him or sell provisions and items obtained from hunting and skinning animals.
Character[]
Personality[]
Benjamin is a vocally cynical individual. He seems to hold the entire town in contempt, likely due to the general lawlessness and filth of his surroundings, and some of his dialogue suggests that he only lives there because the constant gunfights between locals and the presence of many dangerous outlaws means he can charge a premium for his wares.