Tobias is encountered on the streets of some towns. He often refers to Marston as "Chicken Head" and will ask for a duel. If Marston accepts then the player will enter a duel. Tobias can be killed or disarmed during the duel. After the duel is over, Marston will get fame, money, and honor if Tobias isn't killed.
In Thieves' Landing, he can be found at Whit McSwain's food stall seemingly managing the transactions. He can also be encountered in the wilderness, where he will challenge Marston to a ssharpshooting contest.
In Undead Nightmare, Tobias can be found defending the town of Armadillo where he is on the balcony above the Gunsmith or on the roof of the Freight Office. If Armadillo is saved and Tobias survives, he will stand in front of the General Store.
Hey there, cowboy. It looks like this little ol' article is a bit puny. I reckon you could impress me by adding to it. Don't be shy now. If you're logged in, it'll help you earn them fancy achievements, too.