|Hold it right there, outlaw!|
This article is littered with spoilers, so I reckon you might ought'a mosey on down the road if you don't want to read any plot details.
Uncle is an aging alcoholic and reformed petty thief. Although borderline dysfunctional, Uncle resides with the Marston family, and is provided with food and shelter at the family ranch in exchange for work he rarely performs. He sometimes manages to contribute, but to his chagrin, he is often viewed by John as lazy and inept. "Uncle" is a nickname, and he is of no biological relation to any of the Marstons (John qualifies this statement with "at least I sincerely hope not.").
Uncle, in his own way, can be viewed as seeking redemption from his life of petty crime by working on the Marston ranch. This parallels the decisions of John and Abigail to leave the Van der Linde gang and lead a normal life.
Red Dead Redemption
After Abigail and Jack are abducted by Edgar Ross and held for ransom, John reluctantly puts Uncle in charge of taking care of the ranch at Beecher's Hope. John is then forcibly sent out to New Austin to hunt down Bill Williamson and Javier Escuella. For the duration of the pursuit of Williamson and Escuella, Marston is not in any kind of contact with Uncle. When John Marston finally returns from his quest to bring his former gang members to justice, he finds the ranch in disrepair and the livestock rustled. Marston continually berates Uncle for his inability to maintain the ranch while John was away.
Uncle continues to live with the Marston family after John's return. Working at the ranch, Uncle can be seen assisting with blacksmithing and animal tending duties. He and John herd cattle on one occasion and break horses on another. At most other times, he can be seen napping around the ranch.
Uncle assists John in fighting the soldiers, showing great competence with a rifle, but is ultimately wounded in the chest. Jack ceases firing and comes to Uncle's side, while John continues fending off soldiers.
John returns to Uncle and thanks him for his sacrifice, Uncle promptly demands that they escape, and then bleeds to death. Jack expresses horror at Uncle's death.
At some point in time after the assault on the ranch, Uncle is buried atop the ridge at Beecher's Hope, in the family plot. His grave marker provides no birth year and his epitaph reads "Impossible to forget."
Uncle makes his first and last appearance in the mission "Love in the Time of Plague".
John, after riding through the intense downpour from the storm, comes home at night to find Uncle has not returned from town, with the family assuming he has taken shelter from the storm. Later that night, while John and Abigail are in bed, Uncle bursts in, zombified, snarling and growling. As John tells Uncle "he don't look so good", Abigail sees Uncle's bloodied, torn up appearance and yelps in horror, putting as much distance between her and Uncle as she can. Uncle slowly approaches John. John then grabs him by the throat and asks what's wrong with him, ending the situation by beating the now undead Uncle over the head with the base of a nearby lamp.
John leaves the bedroom to go fetch his gun, leaving the disgusted Abigail to look at the beaten Uncle lying on the floor. As John is grabbing his shotgun from his workshop, Uncle chases Abigail out to the front porch. She trips in the yard near the porch, and Uncle takes the opportunity to jump Abigail and bite her on the neck, infecting her. John, arriving to see Uncle had already jumped Abigail, yells at Uncle, causing him to turn and face John. John then proceeds to shoot him in the head, putting Uncle out of his misery.
During this encounter, he has a deep gash crossing down diagonally from the top of his forehead to his left eye. He's missing his hat, revealing the bald spot atop his head. The part of his beard below his mouth is matted with blood, suggesting that he had already infected another victim or had been vomiting blood. His eyes appear to be heavily bloodshot with dried streaks of blood under his eyes, possibly from blood running out of his eyes. His clothes appear bloody and tattered, suggesting he either put up a fight trying to kill whatever infected him, or he received heavy resistance when he attacked one of his previous victims.
Red Dead Redemption
- "The Outlaw's Return"
- "By Sweat and Toil" (Boss)
- "A Continual Feast" (Boss)
- "Spare The Love, Spoil The Child"
- "The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed" (†)
- “You always were a hard and nasty man, John Marston.”
- — Uncle responding to John's idle death threat ("By Sweat and Toil")
- “It's easy to pick on the elderly. It's easy, but it ain't dignified.”
- — Uncle to John Marston ("By Sweat and Toil")
- “Ain't time, John. I ain't gonna make it off this porch anyhow. You take Jack and Abiga...(coughs). Take them and (coughs). Don't worry about me, just get them out of here. ”
- — Uncle's last words ("The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed")
- "I'll bed y'all down!"
- "Back the hell off!"
- "You're dead, ya son of a bitch!"
- "You're mine, ya bastard!"
- "Leave us alone!"
- "Come on, then!"
- "You ain't gettin' away with this!"
- It is implied by Uncle, while riding back to the ranch with the horses in "A Continual Feast", that he once was a rancher who owned his own spread.
- Uncle can be seen with a yellow-brown residue in his beard, implying his drinking habits.
- In Undead Nightmare, the unidentified yellow stain on his beard seems to be replaced with blood.
- John and Uncle were former drinking buddies. This is made clear when John says, "This is why they say 'don't hire the people you drink with."
- When the player walks by prostitutes, Jack may say "Uncle told me about girls like you," or "Uncle warned me about women like you."
- After hearing stories at a campfire, John will sometimes comment that he "knows an old drunk who would love that one." He is most likely referring to Uncle.
- During the Marston Ranch chapter, the player can actually shoot Uncle's hat off, and then in any mission cutscenes, he is seen without his hat.
- Uncle cannot be looted after his death scene, most likely because it would be rather disrespecting.
- In the opening cinematic of "Undead Nightmare", a skeletal right hand is seen briefly below a window of the Marston residence, possibly Uncle's uncovered and rotted right hand.
- Uncle can sometimes be seen smoking at the dinner table in Beecher's Hope at around 8:40 PM.
- The player can throw dynamite, fire bottles, and throwing knives at Uncle to kill him.
- Edgar Ross wears an outfit similar to Uncle's in the Stranger side mission "Remember My Family".
- In Multiplayer, Uncle's mouth doesn't move when the player taunts.
- Uncle thinks John is cruel, harsh and too hard on him, however this is mostly because Uncle is work-shy and falls asleep on the job.
- Uncle wears one glove on his right hand in single player, but two gloves in multiplayer.
- Despite John's accusations of laziness, Uncle can often be seen performing various tasks at Beecher's Hope, such as mending the corn silo's ladder with a hammer and crafting horseshoes outside the barn.
- Despite John's repeated berations, Uncle seems to genuinely care for the Marstons, going as far as to lay down his life for the Marston family.
- It appears John only calls him "Uncle" when speaking to other people, as he almost always just calls him "Old Man" while speaking to him personally. The only apparent time John calls him Uncle to his face would be in Undead Nightmare, when he yells "Uncle! You dumb son of a bitch, stop!" at undead Uncle.
- Rarely if you shoot Uncle's hat off he will keep his gun out instead of it being holstered.
- It is implied that Uncle has some illegitimate children as John tells Jack in "Wolves, Dogs and Sons" that Uncle is "probably lots of people's father."